As reimbursement rates drop and insurance processes become increasingly complex, more physical therapists are considering a cash-only practice. While it’s tempting to skip insurance red tape, increase your revenue and deliver care without third-party interference, an all-cash PT business isn’t right for everyone.
Why Are Cash-Based Physical Therapy Practices Gaining Popularity?
More PTs are considering cash-only models as they transition from employee to employer. Existing practice owners are motivated by frustration with low pay and administrative headaches. By going cash, physical therapists hope to:
- Capture more value from each visit
- Avoid insurance documentation and authorizations
- Spend more time treating patients instead of taking notes for third parties
The model can feel liberating, but it comes with trade-offs.
What Are The Limitations of a Cash-Based Physical Therapy Practice Compared to Insurance Models?
A cash-only PT practice is often a high-paying small business but not often a scalable one. Most cash practices are run by a solo therapist or a duo at most. Patients usually come for your expertise, not your brand. That makes it harder to expand into a larger clinic with full-time staff members. “Patients paying cash are usually paying for the guru –– the therapist with a very high skill set or specialized niche,” says Brian Gallagher, PT, a business expert and founder of MEG, Business Management. LLC
Contrast that with any one of the insurance-based clinical models . While margins per visit are lower, the ability to employ more therapists and bill at scale often results in a more valuable long-term business. “Consider whether you want to create a high-paying job for yourself or turn this into a business model that can expand and sustain itself,” says Gallagher.
Bottom line: Cash-only PT clinics offer flexibility and strong personal income, but it’s usually a lifestyle business and not a growth engine.
How to Start a Cash-Based Physical Therapy Business (and When to Add Insurance)
PTs looking to open a cash-based practice should consider one of these three routes:
- Mom-and-pop boutique practice
A solo business (or with one additional therapist), which provides a solid income with the PT owners’ desired flexibility. - Cash-based first as a step to something greater
Begin as a cash-only operation, then strategically add top-paying insurers from your area, such as Medicare, Blue Cross and others. This will provide you with greater exposure to prospective clients, helping to establish your brand and reputation for clinical excellence. This makes hiring easier and creates greater financial stability. - Hybrid model (the “best of both worlds”)
This has historically been the most successful approach for many PT owners seeking greater viability and long-term sustainability. With approximately 75% of your patients coming from preferred insurance carriers and the remaining 25% being cash-based, you have the best of both worlds. Hybrid practices, on average, collect more per visit than traditional all “in network providers” and enjoy the flexibility of advanced treatment modalities and services that may not be covered in network.
How Do Cash-Based PT Practices Attract Patients Who Pay Out of Pocket?
Convincing patients to pay out of pocket requires strong messaging, especially for those who answer your phones. Successful conversations with clients considering paying cash for your services need to emphasize:
- Freedom from restrictions: You’re not limited by insurance rules dictating what treatments you can provide.
- Holistic care: Position yourself as a lifelong provider focused on optimal health, not just rehab for a single injury.
- Time and attention: Cash clients often value longer sessions and the ability to truly be heard without having their provider fill out third-party notes throughout the session.
Many clinics succeed by repositioning themselves as boutique or concierge services, rather than simply offering “out-of-network” physical therapy. This is especially true when you offer services not always covered by insurance, like red light therapy. “In a cash practice, you’re not just treating people for conditions — you’re caring for patients for life,” says Gallagher.
What Mistakes Should You Avoid When Starting a Cash-Only Physical Therapy Clinic?
If you’re exploring a cash-based model, beware of these pitfalls:
- Overselling your services. Avoid creating unrealistic “luxury” expectations among patients paying cash. Patients should value your time and expertise instead.
- Underpricing. Don’t copy competitors mindlessly. Know your market, and remember that massage therapists often charge $80+ per session. With a DPT degree, your pricing should reflect the higher level of expertise.
- Niching down too soon. Starting with a too narrow niche, such as only runners or only pelvic floor issues, can limit your growth. Build a broad patient base first, then specialize once you’re financially stable and know what areas you prefer.
What Are the Compliance and Insurance Risks of a Cash-Based PT Practice?
Just because you accept cash doesn’t mean you can ignore the fact that you are still a licensed practice therapist within the profession’s practice act. The following are some insurance and compliance risks to know before taking cash for physical therapy services:
In-network vs. out-of-network restrictions
If you’re contracted with a particular insurance carrier, you must comply with your contractual agreement and not try to bypass this by manipulating the rules you have to practice under, as it may land you in breach of contract.
Medicare patients
If a service is covered by Medicare, you’re required to bill Medicare, even if a patient prefers to pay cash. You can only charge cash for services delivered to a Medicare patient if it’s considered a non-covered service, and even then, you need to have all the proper documentation in order.
Disclosures for cash-pay
You may need patients to sign a form acknowledging you’re not billing insurance. Failure to comply could result in penalties or board action.
Professional liability insurance
Cash-based PT practices often operate in non-traditional settings, such as gyms, homes, or coworking spaces. Some liability policies don’t extend coverage outside of a controlled, compliant clinical environment. Make sure your medmal liability insurance covers all the places where you treat patients.
Is a Cash-Based Physical Therapy Practice Right For You – or Is an Insurance or Hybrid Model Better?
The decision comes down to your goals. If you want independence, flexible hours and strong per-visit revenue, some level of a cash-based model may work for you. If you want to scale, hire staff and build a higher-value clinic, then a hybrid or insurance-based model may be more sustainable. “Most cash practices won’t scale beyond a family practice size of 1-2 providers. And that’s fine, but it’s important to know what you’re building,” says Gallagher.
Key takeaway: Going cash-based isn’t just about avoiding insurance headaches. It’s about choosing what kind of business you see as most in line with your goals long term.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What are the pros and cons of a cash-based physical therapy practice? The biggest benefits of a cash-only PT clinic include higher per-visit revenue, more time with patients, and freedom from insurance restrictions. However, downsides include limited scalability, challenges expanding beyond 1–2 providers, and the need for strong patient education to justify out-of-pocket costs.
- Can physical therapists accept cash from Medicare patients? No, if a service is covered by Medicare, you must bill Medicare—even if the patient wants to pay cash. You may only accept cash for non-covered services, and you’ll need proper documentation and signed disclosures to remain compliant.
- How do cash-based PT practices attract patients willing to pay out of pocket? Successful cash PT clinics emphasize benefits like personalized care, longer one-on-one sessions, and holistic treatment options not always covered by insurance. Positioning your practice as a boutique or concierge service helps patients see the value in choosing cash-pay physical therapy.
Click here to learn more about CM&F’s physical therapist malpractice insurance, also known as physical therapist professional liability insurance.
